HC rules settlement with victim's family no ground to quash POCSO case

The Kerala High Court has ruled that criminal proceedings under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act cannot ordinarily be quashed solely on the basis of a settlement between the accused and the victim or the victim's family, even if the alleged offence is of comparatively lesser gravity. The court said that allowing such settlements to determine the outcome of prosecutions would undermine the protective purpose of the legislation and could expose vulnerable victims to pressure and inducement.A Division Bench comprising Justices Raja Vijayaraghavan V and KV Jayakumar delivered the ruling on November 5 while answering a reference made by a Single Bench over conflicting judicial views on whether POCSO cases could be quashed following a settlement between the parties.The Bench held that the fact that a victim attains majority during the pendency of criminal proceedings and subsequently expresses no objection to their termination does not, by itself, extinguish the offence or provide sufficient grounds to quash the prosecution."The criminal justice system cannot permit offences against children to be converted into private disputes capable of being resolved through a negotiated settlement," the Bench observed.The court emphasised that even sexual assault involving physical contact, without the more aggravated forms of sexual violence, could have serious consequences for a child's dignity, bodily integrity and psychological well-being."Even an act of sexual assault involving physical contact of a child, though not accompanied by the more aggravated forms of sexual violence, may have serious consequences for the child's dignity, bodily integrity and psychological well-being," the Court observed.The reference arose from a case involving a 49-year-old man, Ummer, who was accused of sexually assaulting a 17-year-old girl while serving as an Ustad at Hibamul Islam Madrassa at Cheruvoth. The allegation was that he repeatedly touched the girl inappropriately on July 1, 2018, and on subsequent days.Based on a complaint lodged by the girl's father on April 24, 2019, Panoor police registered a case under Section 354A(1)(i) of the IPC (sexual harassment) and Sections 7 (sexual assault), 8 (punishment for sexual assault), 9(l) (aggravated sexual assault by staff of an educational institution), 9(f) (aggravated sexual assault by a person in a position of trust) and 10 (punishment for aggravated sexual assault) of the POCSO Act.The accused had initially approached the High Court seeking to quash the criminal proceedings, producing an affidavit from the victim in support of his plea. The court declined to accept the affidavit as a ground for terminating the proceedings.Subsequently, after attaining majority, the victim filed another affidavit stating that the complaint had been lodged due to a mistaken impression and that she had been ill-advised by certain persons inimical towards the accused. She also stated that she had no grievance against him and that the continued proceedings were adversely affecting her future prospects.The accused relied on these developments and cited Supreme Court and Delhi High Court judgments in support of his plea that POCSO proceedings could be quashed in appropriate circumstances following a settlement.However, the Division Bench said that the POCSO Act was enacted to protect children from sexual assault, harassment and exploitation, recognising their vulnerability and their inability to fully comprehend the consequences of sexual conduct.It noted that offences under the Act are not merely offences against an individual but also implicate the larger public interest in ensuring that children grow up in an environment free from sexual abuse.The Bench also cautioned that a settlement or an affidavit submitted by a victim cannot invariably be treated as a free and voluntary expression of her wishes. Such decisions could be influenced by pressure, coercion, social circumstances, economic dependence or inducement, particularly where the accused occupies a position of authority or influence over the victim."The court cannot abdicate its responsibility by accepting a settlement at face value," the judges observed, adding that the inherent powers of the High Court must be exercised independently after considering the allegations, the materials collected during investigation and the larger interests of justice.Distinction between lesser and aggravated offencesThe Bench specifically rejected the argument that offences under Sections 7 and 8 of the POCSO Act, which deal with sexual assault and its punishment, could be treated differently from more aggravated forms of sexual offences when considering settlement-based quashing.It said that describing an offence as being of lesser gravity cannot be a reason to dilute the legislative intent behind the Act. Even sexual assault involving physical contact, without more aggravated forms of sexual violence, could have serious consequences for a

Nov 18, 2026 - 07:30
Nov 18, 2026 - 07:33
 0  6
HC rules settlement with victim's family no ground to quash POCSO case

THE Kerala High Court has ruled that criminal proceedings under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act cannot ordinarily be quashed solely based on a settlement between the accused and the victim or the victim's family, even if the alleged offence is of comparatively lesser gravity.

The court said that allowing such settlements to determine the outcome of prosecutions would undermine the protective purpose of the legislation and could expose vulnerable victims to pressure and inducement.

A Division Bench comprising Justices Raja Vijayaraghavan V and KV Jayakumar delivered the ruling on November 5 while answering a reference made by a Single Bench over conflicting judicial views on whether POCSO cases could be quashed following a settlement between the parties.

The Bench held that the fact that a victim attains majority during the pendency of criminal proceedings and subsequently expresses no objection to their termination does not, by itself, extinguish the offence or provide sufficient grounds to quash the prosecution.

"The criminal justice system cannot permit offences against children to be converted into private disputes capable of being resolved through a negotiated settlement," the Bench observed.

The court emphasised that even sexual assault involving physical contact, without the more aggravated forms of sexual violence, could have serious consequences for a child's dignity, bodily integrity and psychological well-being.

"Even an act of sexual assault involving physical contact of a child, though not accompanied by the more aggravated forms of sexual violence, may have serious consequences for the child's dignity, bodily integrity and psychological well-being," the Court observed.

The reference arose from a case involving a 49-year-old man, Ummer, who was accused of sexually assaulting a 17-year-old girl while serving as an Ustad at Hibamul Islam Madrassa at Cheruvoth. The allegation was that he repeatedly touched the girl inappropriately on July 1, 2018, and on subsequent days.

Based on a complaint lodged by the girl's father on April 24, 2019, Panoor police registered a case under Section 354A(1)(i) of the IPC (sexual harassment) and Sections 7 (sexual assault), 8 (punishment for sexual assault), 9(l) (aggravated sexual assault by staff of an educational institution), 9(f) (aggravated sexual assault by a person in a position of trust) and 10 (punishment for aggravated sexual assault) of the POCSO Act.

The accused had initially approached the High Court seeking to quash the criminal proceedings, producing an affidavit from the victim in support of his plea. The court declined to accept the affidavit as a ground for terminating the proceedings.

Subsequently, after attaining majority, the victim filed another affidavit stating that the complaint had been lodged due to a mistaken impression and that she had been ill-advised by certain persons inimical towards the accused. She also stated that she had no grievance against him and that the continued proceedings were adversely affecting her future prospects.

The accused relied on these developments and cited Supreme Court and Delhi High Court judgments in support of his plea that POCSO proceedings could be quashed in appropriate circumstances following a settlement.

However, the Division Bench said that the POCSO Act was enacted to protect children from sexual assault, harassment and exploitation, recognising their vulnerability and their inability to fully comprehend the consequences of sexual conduct.

It noted that offences under the Act are not merely offences against an individual but also implicate the larger public interest in ensuring that children grow up in an environment free from sexual abuse.

The Bench also cautioned that a settlement or an affidavit submitted by a victim cannot invariably be treated as a free and voluntary expression of her wishes. Such decisions could be influenced by pressure, coercion, social circumstances, economic dependence or inducement, particularly where the accused occupies a position of authority or influence over the victim.

"The court cannot abdicate its responsibility by accepting a settlement at face value," the judges observed, adding that the inherent powers of the High Court must be exercised independently after considering the allegations, the materials collected during investigation and the larger interests of justice.

Distinction between lesser and aggravated offences

The Bench specifically rejected the argument that offences under Sections 7 and 8 of the POCSO Act, which deal with sexual assault and its punishment, could be treated differently from more aggravated forms of sexual offences when considering settlement-based quashing.

It said that describing an offence as being of lesser gravity cannot be a reason to dilute the legislative intent behind the Act. Even sexual assault involving physical contact, without more aggravated forms of sexual violence, could have serious consequences for a child's dignity, bodily integrity and psychological well-being.

The Court also clarified that the victim's subsequent attainment of majority does not retrospectively change the legal character of an alleged act committed when she was a child.

High Court retains power to quash cases on merits

While laying down restrictions on settlement-based quashing, the Division Bench clarified that the High Court's inherent powers under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure or the corresponding Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) have not been taken away.

It said that proceedings could still be quashed where an independent examination of the First Information Report, final report and investigation materials establishes that the essential ingredients of the alleged offence are not made out, the allegations are inherently improbable, or the proceedings are frivolous, vexatious or amount to an abuse of the process of law.

The Bench, however, emphasised that such a decision must be based on the merits of the case and recognised legal principles, and not merely on an agreement between the accused and the victim.

Answering the reference, the court held that POCSO proceedings cannot ordinarily be quashed solely on the basis of a settlement or compromise, even where the alleged offence is of comparatively lesser gravity.